The Historical-Cultural Comtext
Week theme: Interpreting Prophetic Writings
This didn't play here. Open the episode page.
Sometimes we understand the words of Scripture but miss what they meant to the people who first heard them.
Today's lesson gives us two examples: Isaiah's description of a child dying at one hundred years old in the new earth, and Paul's instruction to greet one another with a holy kiss. Both require us to look beyond the words to understand the message.
Isaiah 65:20 troubles me. If he is describing the new heavens and the new earth, why does he mention death and sinners? We teach that neither will exist in God's final kingdom.
This is uncomfortable. We confidently teach from Revelation 21:4 that death will be no more. Yet Isaiah appears to describe something different. Do we give Revelation the final say and then explain Isaiah away?
We must first consider Isaiah's historical setting. He was addressing a people who understood God's covenant promises. Deuteronomy 28 describes the blessings associated with faithfulness, including security and long life, and the consequences of disobedience.
Israel had experienced judgment, suffering and displacement. Isaiah uses the language of extraordinary longevity, children surviving and secure homes to portray the restoration God desired for His people. A person dying at one hundred would be regarded as having died young.
The prophet connects this restoration with the greater hope of a new creation. The blessings Israel could experience would be a foretaste of what God ultimately intended. They were not a description of death continuing in the final kingdom.
Isaiah himself declares that God will swallow up death forever (Isaiah 25:8), speaks of the resurrection (Isaiah 26:19), and promises that weeping and crying will cease (Isaiah 65:19). We cannot isolate verse 20 and make it contradict the larger testimony of the prophet.
But how do we know when a passage is symbolic? Could we not use that explanation whenever a text challenges something we believe?
We are comfortable identifying symbols in Daniel and Revelation. But are we equally willing to examine our own interpretations? Or do we call a passage symbolic when a literal reading becomes inconvenient?
That is a legitimate warning. We must not use symbolism as an escape from difficult passages. We examine the historical setting, literary form, immediate context and the testimony of Scripture as a whole.
And we must apply the same standard to our own doctrines that we apply to the beliefs of other churches. Knowing our doctrines does not make us immune to misinterpreting Scripture. An interpretation does not become correct simply because it has been repeated for generations.
Now consider Paul's instruction in 1 Corinthians 16:20: "Greet one another with a holy kiss."
If Paul instructed Christians to greet one another with a kiss, why don't we do that in our churches?
Who decides which biblical instructions are cultural and which are binding? Are we simply choosing the practices that suit us?
In Paul's time, a kiss was a customary expression of affection among relatives and close friends. Paul was encouraging believers to extend that warmth to one another as members of God's family.
He repeats the instruction in Romans 16:16, 2 Corinthians 13:12 and 1 Thessalonians 5:26. The enduring principle is genuine Christian affection and fellowship, not one particular physical greeting. A handshake or appropriate embrace can communicate the same welcome in another culture.
But changing the expression does not release us from practising the love behind it.
Then perhaps we have preserved the greeting but lost the fellowship. Visitors receive handshakes and smiles, yet some attend for months without anyone learning their names. Members can sit in the same congregation for years and still feel like outsiders. Is that Christian fellowship?
No. Romans 12:10 calls us to be kindly affectionate toward one another, and Hebrews 13:2 encourages hospitality. A handshake that conceals indifference is not the spirit of Paul's instruction. Christian fellowship requires genuine interest, acceptance and care.
So we can be careful about preserving our doctrines and church practices while neglecting the principles they are supposed to produce?
Exactly. Isaiah reminds us that historical context matters when interpreting Scripture. Paul reminds us that cultural context matters when applying it. In both cases, we must understand the message rather than merely repeat the words.
As Adventists, we take pride in being people of the Bible. But does knowing our doctrines guarantee that we have understood every passage correctly, and preserving our customs guarantee that we are practising their purpose?
Are we allowing Scripture to correct our understanding and shape our behaviour, or are our inherited beliefs and customs deciding what we are willing to hear and practise?